Planting Techniques for the Standard "p-a-m-i" Tremolo
Benefits of planting:
Planting tends to keep the fingers and thumb close to the string. Staying close to the strings helps to keep tremolo finger movements small for improved accuracy.
Planting may improve the tone quality of the thumb and fingers.
Planting helps the player to consistently contact the strings with the fingers on the left side of the fingernails with the flesh and nail simultaneously.
It also helps the player consistently contact the strings with the thumb on the center to right side of the thumbnail with the flesh and thumbnail simultaneously.
When the thumb and fingers contact the strings correctly, the tone will be round and full, with very little extraneous noise.
Planting may be done in four ways:
✦ ✦ ✦
№1
Plant the "a" finger as the thumb plays.
Many people recommend this. Here's why:
It is said that if the "a" finger is planted it serves as a reference point for "i" and "m", increasing their accuracy.
Having the "a" finger on the string keeps "i" and "m" closer to the string as well.
Some say it aids in developing speed.
It also aids in hand stability.
It certainly results in smaller movements of the "a" finger.
Security: It provides a sense of security, especially in performance situations where nerves might affect your playing. With the "a" finger planted, you have a stable starting point.
Two schools of thought exist:
One school says that the planting of "a" is a practice technique for slower tempos and that as the speed is increased, the finger is no longer consciously planted.
The other school says that the plant is maintained even at high speeds.
Try both and see what produces the best result for you.
Note:
A downside of this technique is that the sound of the string is cut off every time the "a" finger is planted. Many prefer to have the sound of the note ring through as the thumb plays.
❧
№2
Plant "a" and "p" together.
Plant them immediately after the "i" finger plays.
Benefits of this approach:
This is said to result in even greater accuracy, speed, and stability.
It specifically helps to rein in extraneous movements of the thumb.
It preps the thumb to play the correct string.
Two schools of thought exist:
One school says this is only a practice technique.
The other school says this plant is used even at final tremolo speeds.
❧
№3
Sequential Planting: Plant all four fingers Option A.
This one is more of a practice technique rather something to be used in actual playing.
Here is how it works:
Start with the thumb and "a" finger planted on their strings.
The thumb plays.
The "a" finger plays.
Immediately after "a" plays, plant the "m" finger. This will cut the previously played note short (staccato).
Immediately after "m" plays plant the "i" finger on the string. Again, this will cut the note just played producing a staccato.
Pluck the string with the "i" finger.
Immediately after the "i" finger plays, plant "p" and "a" simultaneously on the strings they will play next. This cuts off the note the "i" finger just played and cuts off the ringing bass string.
At first, it is practiced at a snail's pace. It will sound as notated in the example above and below.
❧
№4
Sequential Planting: Plant all four fingers Option B.
Method four is the same as method #3, except that at the end of the tremolo pattern:
After the "i" finger plucks, only plant "p" on its string rather than both "p" and "a."
Finally, as "p" plucks, plant "a."
Important:
Again, this is a practice technique or strategy. It is not used in performance.
Benefits and progression:
It definitely helps limit the movements of the fingers.
Each finger stroke pulls the next finger immediately into position.
As the speed is increased the individual finger preparations and the resulting staccato become less distinct.
As you approach tremolo tempo (MM=144+ for a quarter note) the staccato effect disappears altogether.
Watch me demonstrate these planting techniques in this video clip:
A Different Perspective:
Douglas Niedt states that he does not use planting in his tremolo. He says that in his experimentation with planting, it had no effect on his speed, accuracy, or control of his finger movements.
But nevertheless, he highly recommends that you try it. Everyone is different. What doesn't work for someone else may be the secret you've been searching for to unlock mastery of the tremolo.
Try everything. Discount nothing.
✦ ✦ ✦
Before you continue...
We recommend printing this "Planting Techniques" page or saving it to your computer for your future reference.
These planting techniques have been compiled based on decades of teaching experience and studying the methods of master guitarists.